Apr, 2004 oxford university press pulled the book because they are fearful of physical violence. Laine said he received over 400 emails related to the issue in over five months, including two death threats. Protests over books, films and writings which hindu or muslim groups find offensive are not new in india. The debate centres significantly on the renaming of india as south asia and. Jani, the highest ranking ranking hindu american in the joe biden for president campaign, serving as the asian american pacific islander outreach director, was the target of an article in a few leftwing publications, followed by a profile in two muslim web portals, muslim matters and middle east eye. The california state board of education sbe on thursday approved 10 textbooks and rejected two, taking on board several demands made by the. Were details of jesus life copied from legends about krishna. Hindu month in california and the lessons from the.
Hindus in california are a minority and thus must define. No stranger to controversy, batra had earlier taken on indian. Mar 28, 2004 i write in regards to the recent controversy over a us scholars history book in india. A controversy in the us state of california concerning the portrayal of hinduism in history textbooks began in 2005. Revisiting the communicative processes surrounding the reform of hindu customary laws relating to marriage, divorce, succession, adoption, and maintenance, the book provides an indepth account of the intense debate that. In the usa, npr, cnn, new york times, new yorker and various other media majors have featured this story in a big way. The texasbased vedic foundation and the american hindu education foundation complained to californias curriculum commission. The controversy over the book, the lives of sri aurobindo, written by americanborn ashram inmate peter heehs, has been raging for a while now, particularly after the. Indian publisher withdraws book, stoking fears of nationalist. Hinduism experts fear lasting effects of controversy over. Wendy doniger, the 74yearold american author and research scholar in sanskrit is moreover known for. A hindu king in islamic india, which explored the life of a 17thcentury icon of.
I write in regards to the recent controversy over a us scholars history book in india. Today there are over 450 hindu temples across the united states. May 25, 2017 history revisited some of the hate mail is chilling. Following the books publication, dinanath batra of the hindu group. The hinduamerican organisations accuse the academics of wanting to erase. Hindu king in islamic india, just as the monsoons storms were arriving in the subcontinent. It was banned in 2005 following claims that it mocked islam and was the work of american evangelists as part of a usisraeli conspiracy. In january, fresh controversy along the same lines erupted over a book by macalester colleges laine, shivaji. Divisions within hinduism, the forehead mark, symbol, hindu websites. Mar 10, 2020 jani, the highest ranking ranking hindu american in the joe biden for president campaign, serving as the asian american pacific islander outreach director, was the target of an article in a few leftwing publications, followed by a profile in two muslim web portals, muslim matters and middle east eye. We express complete support towards a multitude of hindu organisations and indian american groups that joined hands to. Hinduamerican foundation is a much needed organization which finally has come into being. Search the history of over 424 billion web pages on the internet. Jun 29, 20 already the younger generation asks what the california textbook affair was.
Penguin books india has reportedly agreed to recall and destroy all copies in india of a book about hinduism by a u. A variety of estimates state that over 500,000 indian american students attend highereducation institutions in any given year. The mindfulness controversy in buddhism, mindfulness is a direct, wholebodyandmind awareness of the present moment. Oxford university press pulled the book because they are fearful of physical violence. The hinduamerican organisations accuse the academics of wanting to erase india itself by recommending the change of name. May 27, 2016 the hindu american organisations accuse the academics of wanting to erase india itself by recommending the change of name. The uproar over the use of native american images as sports team mascots mystifies many in americas majority culture. This awareness includes awareness of ones body, of sensations, of mental states, and of everything both within and without oneself. An alternative history, has, not unsurprisingly, elicited a huge volume and range of responses. James baldwins go tell it on the mountain was a brilliant debut about a 14yearold african american boy being saved in a christian church in harlem. Bollywood film about legendary hindu queen embroiled in controversy.
It examines the mediation, representation and construction of multiple forms of hinduism in a variety of social and political contexts, and in the process establishes it as a dynamic and developing modern concept. In 1968, the american newspaper publishers association awarded the hindu its world press achievement award. The decision by penguin india to withdraw wendy donigers controversial book,the hindus. The hindu can claim to be the most respected paper in india. Controversy quotes quotes about controversy yourdictionary. Author wendy doniger talks of the country, democracy and how her life has changed post her book being banned. What the controversy over american dirt tells us about. Time magazine reports that in 2011, the hindu nationalist group shiksha bachao andolan filed a civil suit against penguin india over the book, claiming that the book was. In the last twenty years, a large number of students have started migrating to the united states to pursue higher education. Indias noted that this isnt the first time donigers book has stirred controversy. Bollywood film about legendary hindu queen embroiled in.
Historian audrey truschke on the backlash to her aurangzeb book the mughal emperor is controversial not. Hinduism in america oxford research encyclopedia of religion. Hindu groups in us demand apology from cnn over controversial series. The texasbased vedic foundation vf and the american hindu education foundation hef citation needed, complained to californias curriculum commission, arguing that the coverage in sixth grade history textbooks of indian history and hinduism was biased against hinduism. Public hinduisms critically analyzes the way in which hinduism is produced and represented as an established feature of modern public landscapes. Hindu groups claim win in california textbooks case over portrayal of hinduism several groups, officials and academics had urged californias education board to reject textbooks portraying. Whats in us academic wendy donigers latest book on hinduism that has. Yet, as i have already said, i am a much more ardent. Hindu month in california and the lessons from the textbook. Ro khanna trounces challenger ritesh tandon who was supported. Ro khanna trounces challenger ritesh tandon who was. What the controversy over american dirt tells us about publishing and authorship were not telling people you cant write about another community, were saying you can, but heres how you do it. May 06, 2016 michael witzel, a harvard university professor of sanskrit who has also been pressing california for changes that hindu advocates have objected to for nearly a decade, said the entire controversy.
Doniger had welcomed creative controversy, but what she got was. This debate touches on the important power that textbooks have on religion and. The texasbased vedic foundation vf and the american hindu education foundation hef, both hindutva hindu nationalist groups,1 complained to californias curriculum commission, saying the coverage in sixth grade history. According to multiple sources, penguin books india has agreed to recall and destroy all copies of american indoligist wendy donigers book the hindus. They say the controversy over the books is part of a larger pattern of political violence against scholars in india. You need to know about the hindu textbook controversy.
State to seek extradition of shivaji author mumbai. California textbook controversy over hindu history wikiquote. Apr 14, 2018 the debate has gone on for over a decade. They discussed at length on faith and religion, and he accused her of sexualising and defaming. Hindu groups in us demand apology from cnn over controversial. Outcry as penguin india pulps alternative history of hindus world. This is the case for californian hindus in the hindu textbook controversy in which hindu advocacy organizations participated in the california textbook adoption process and partially attained their goal of modifying the text in accordance with their agendas. We express complete support towards a multitude of hindu organisations and. State to seek extradition of shivaji author mumbai news. A wrinkle in times long religious controversy history. Michael witzel, a harvard university professor of sanskrit who has also been pressing california for changes that hindu advocates have objected to for. Sports fans love to don paint and feathers to cheer on the washington redskins and the cleveland indians. In 2003, a book on the hindu god ganesh by one of donigers students was. The 800page book includes over 50 pages of references and covers a vast history that spans 50 million yearsa magnum opus from a highly acclaimed scholar of hindu traditions.
Mar 12, 2017 hindu groups in us demand apology from cnn over controversial series. Last october, hindu american activists in the bay area, incensed over khannas recent tweet denouncing hindutva and his joining the congressional caucus on pakistan and his defiant refusal to withdraw his membership, promoted tandon, and erstwhile tech entrepreneurto run against khanna in californias 17th district, which incorporates. In march 2010, hindu american foundation cofounder aseem shukla debated various elements from the book with doniger herself on a washington postsponsored blog. Debate erupts in california over curriculum on indias. Critics keep on implying i wrote the book and mark tully did not. Its a sensitive subject, one that must be handled delicately, lest a filmmaker incite the fury of millions of believers all. If darwin s discovery had been made in a taoist or shinto, hindu or animist culture it would very likely have become just one more strand in its intertwining mythologies. Nov 10, 2017 the california state board of education sbe on thursday approved 10 textbooks and rejected two, taking on board several demands made by the hindu american foundation haf and dismissing. The controversy over the book, the lives of sri aurobindo, written by americanborn ashram inmate peter heehs, has been raging for a while now, particularly after the group opposed to the book. The controversy over who wrote hindutva, sex and adventuresroly books, new delhi.
As some of you may know, james laine, a professor of religious studies at macalester college in mn, has published a book through oxford university press entitled shivaji. Yet, as i have already said, i am a much more ardent and militant defender of hindus than mark tully ever was and will ever be. The mindfulness controversy of buddhism vs psychology. There will be a chilling effect on what topics you choose to do. Apr 14, 2017 making a movie about religion is a surefire way to court controversy. Now that california has been endowed with a hindu awareness month in a resolution coauthored by the hindu american foundation, the first one scheduled for this coming october, hindus are enthusiastic that they will be able to show off their culture.
The book was initially published by viking penguin in 2009 and later in india by penguins indian subsidiary, penguin india. Hinduphobia in america and the end of irony opinion. The texasbased vedic foundation vf and the american hindu education foundation hef, complained to californias curriculum commission, arguing that the coverage in sixth grade history textbooks of indian history and hinduism was biased against hinduism. The hindutva, sex and adventures continuing controversy. Throughout nearly a century of its publication the hindu has exerted wide influence not only in madras but throughout india. An alternative history is a book by american indologist, wendy doniger which the author describes as an alternative to the narrative of hindu history that they tell.
On one side are those who see the issue solely as one of freedom of expression and worry that penguins capitulation undermines free speech. Sports and the controversy over american indian mascots carol spindel on. Indian censorship and the curious case of wendy doniger huffpost. Global hinduism experts fear lasting effects of controversy over scholars book anindito mukherjee, epa, landov hindu nationalists rallied outside the u. Even salman rushdies book the satanic verses was banned in india by a. Aseem shukla of the hindu american foundation debated various elements of the book with doniger herself on his blog. Laine following allegations that it hurts the sentiments of people who adore the warriorking. One of the first major discussions of hinduism in the united states was swami vivekanandas address to the worlds parliament of religions in chicago in 1893. Ashutosh, the author of a new book called hindu rashtra hindu nation, said the appeal of hindu supremacy was rooted in the failure of communism. The most controversial books of all time readers digest. In 2010, an online petition to penguin usa backed by the sarasvati research trust, had over 10,000 people sign to demand that the book be withdrawn. These groups also seek to remove references to caste prejudice in the. Already the younger generation asks what the california textbook affair was.
California textbook controversy over hindu history wikipedia. Hinduism came to the united states first in the american imagination and only second with emissaries and immigrants from india. For a minority, however, anything not written simply. History revisited some of the hate mail is chilling. Adhikara and the academy the bogus controversy over. The initial features of hinduism that captivated north american audiences were those that were lauded for their compatibility with protestant christianity and those that were derided for their incompatibility with the same. An alternative history, first published in 2009, was recalled and pulped by penguin.
The maharashtra government bans one more book on shivaji by the american scholar james w. You need to know about the hindu textbook controversy world. An alternative history is a book by american indologist, wendy. The real reason wendy donigers book on hindus was banned in. For those as in the dark as i was, the controversy is that a sanskrit scholar who is a white, american, jewish woman has written a book called the hindus and apparently offers some radically. Since its publication in 1962, a wrinkle in time has become one of the mostfrequently banned or challenged books, for multiple reasons. The laine controversy and the study of hinduism christian lee novetzke in 2003 oxford university press released a book by james w. Many indian scholars have rushed to the defense of the american authors.
Apr 27, 2010 the controversy over who wrote hindutva, sex and adventuresroly books, new delhi. So, it is primarily the juxtaposition of sex and hinduism in the book that bothers you. Wendy donigers the hindus recalled by penguin india time. Hindu american foundation is a much needed organization which finally has come into being. Most of you know of the recent media controversy over penguins decision to withdraw wendy donigers book, the hindus. That petition stated that the book was riddled with factual errors and mistranslations. But past experience shows that hindus are not good at selling.
Apr 10, 2004 in january, fresh controversy along the same lines erupted over a book by macalester colleges laine, shivaji. This hullaballoo over plagiarism is just a fig leaf for a deeper fundamental problem that these scholars have adhikara and the academy the bogus controversy over rajiv malhotra and. A book, a controversy, and the ominous aftermath in 2009, penguin books published the hindus. Apr 11, 2019 ashutosh, the author of a new book called hindu rashtra hindu nation, said the appeal of hindu supremacy was rooted in the failure of communism, which used to have mainstream appeal here. Wendy donigers book is a tribute to hinduisms complexity, not an. Mar 08, 2020 last october, hindu american activists in the bay area, incensed over khannas recent tweet denouncing hindutva and his joining the congressional caucus on pakistan and his defiant refusal to withdraw his membership, promoted tandon, and erstwhile tech entrepreneurto run against khanna in californias 17th district, which incorporates. I truly believe that most readers would not find the book offensive or controversial. In buddhism, mindfulness is a direct, wholebodyandmind awareness of the present moment.
Hindu groups claim win in california textbooks case over. The texasbased vedic foundation vf and the american hindu education foundation hef, both hindutva hindu nationalist groups,1 complained to californias curriculum commission, saying the coverage in sixth grade history textbooks of indian history and hinduism was biased against hinduism. The real reason wendy donigers book on hindus was banned in india. Controversy over books on hinduism by religion scholar wendy doniger continues to grow. Almost daily there have been extensive tv and major print media discusions in india. Historian audrey truschke on the backlash to her aurangzeb book the mughal emperor is controversial not so much because of indias past. The book explores a significant episode of indian social history, the hindu code bill controversy that stirred the indian social consciousness in the midtwentieth century. Maharashtra home minister r r patil will seek interpols help in extraditing american scholar james laine for his controversial book shivaji. Making a movie about religion is a surefire way to court controversy. A simple perusal of the american library associations banned book list, for example, will yield countless examples of religious objections to. He spent two years in the united states, and lectured in several cities including detroit, boston, and new york.
Under modi, a hindu nationalist surge has further divided. The wendy doniger controversy and the need for hindu. Many times i felt frustrated seeing wrong depiction of hinduism in books, newspapers, tv, movies, radio etc. It concerns how india and hinduism is portrayed in social studies books.
49 27 134 716 175 1362 22 424 675 774 1440 101 507 1277 877 796 395 296 1248 420 6 379 1573 568 814 555 627 1027 766 381 300 572 48